Looking for car keys or key fobs? Visit Spare Me Car Keys →

Rekey & lock change

Lost Your House Keys in Riverton? What to Do Next

Satin nickel deadbolt and two house keys on a table, the kind of spare keys we cut for Riverton homes

Lost your house keys in Riverton? It happens to everyone: a key ring left at the park, dropped in the snow, or gone with a bag that went missing. The first question is simple. Could the person who has them now find your door? Here is how to decide whether to just make a spare, rekey, or replace your locks, and what to do about the other keys and remotes that were on the same ring.

Lost keys? Here's the short answer

If there is any chance the keys can be tied to your address, rekey the locks they open. Rekeying changes the pins inside your existing locks, so the lost keys stop working and new keys do.

Call or text 307-206-4218.

Step 1: Figure out what was on the ring

Before you call anyone, write down everything that was on that key ring. A lost ring often holds more than one key, and each one has its own fix.

Brass house keys on a ring with a fob, plus lock cylinders, like the keys a Riverton homeowner might lose
  • House keys: front door, back door, garage entry door, and any deadbolts.
  • Garage door remote or opener fob, if it was clipped on.
  • Padlock keys: shed, gate, trailer, storage unit, or job box.
  • Work keys: office, shop, or business doors.
  • Car key or fob.
  • Anything with your name, address, or plate on it: a tag, a mail key, a gym card, or a wallet that was lost with the keys.

Step 2: Decide how much risk there is

Not every lost key needs a lock change. What matters is whether the keys can be connected to your door.

Lower risk

One loose key, no tag, lost somewhere far from home, with nothing on it that points to your address. A spare copy from a key you still have may be all you need.

Higher risk

Keys lost with a wallet, ID, mail, or anything with your address. Keys lost near your house. A garage remote on the same ring. Keys that were taken, not just dropped. Rekey.

Not sure

If you can't say for sure where they went, treat it as higher risk. Rekeying the doors those keys open puts you back in control of who can get in.

Step 3: Spare key, rekey, or replace?

OptionWhat it doesWhen it fits
Make a spare keyCuts another copy of a key you still have. The lost key still works.Low risk, and you still have at least one working key.
RekeyChanges the pins inside your existing lock. The lost key stops working, and we cut new keys.The locks work fine and you just need the lost keys dead.
ReplaceTakes the old lock off and installs a new one.The lock is worn or damaged, or you want an upgrade like a new deadbolt or a keypad.

A key-copy machine only gives you another key to the same lock. It does nothing about the key that is out there. When keys could be tied to your home, rekeying is what changes who can get in. Our rekey and lock change page explains how it works.

Spare Me locksmith at the mobile key-cutting workstation on a Riverton-area service call

Rekey every door the lost key opened

If your front door and back door took the same key, rekey both. Any door left on the old key is still a door the lost key opens. While we're there, we can rekey your doors so they all run on one new key (keyed alike), which means fewer keys on the new ring.

Satin nickel deadbolt on a wood door with strike plates and screws, the hardware we rekey or replace for Riverton homes
  • Front, back, and side entry knobs and levers
  • Deadbolts
  • The entry door from the garage into the house
  • Any other door the lost key fit

Most standard residential locks can be rekeyed. Some worn, damaged, or specialty cylinders are better replaced. We check on site and tell you which option fits.

Don't forget the garage door remote

If a garage door remote was on the ring with your house keys, the person holding it has a way into your garage, and often into the house through the garage entry door. Rekeying the house doesn't change that. We can remove the lost remote from your opener, program a replacement remote, and set up a wireless keypad. See our garage door remote and keypad programming page.

Black two-button garage door remote we can program for a Riverton home after a lost opener is removed

Padlock keys and work keys

  • Padlocks: some padlocks can be rekeyed and some can't. If yours can't, a new padlock is often the simpler fix. We carry padlocks for sheds, gates, and trailers, including keyed-alike sets. See our padlocks page.
  • SFIC padlocks and doors: on a small format interchangeable core system, access can be changed by swapping the core instead of buying a new lock. See our SFIC padlock page.
  • Business keys: tell the owner or manager so they can decide what to rekey. For staff keys, rekeys, and master key systems, see our commercial locksmith page.
  • Car keys: Spare Me Car Keys, our sister company, handles car keys and fobs. Visit sparemecarkeys.com.

If you lost your only key

If you can't get in at all, we help with home and business lockouts in Riverton and Lander. Once you're in, we can rekey the locks so the lost key stops working, and cut new keys for everyone who needs one.

Thinking about new locks instead?

If your locks are worn, sticky, or you've been meaning to upgrade, a lost key is a good time to replace them. These deadbolts are from our door locks page. Prices are per lock.

Keypad deadbolt and keyed knob installed on a door in Riverton, Wyoming
Schlage single cylinder deadbolt in satin nickel

Schlage single cylinder deadbolt

Our price: $45.00

Key outside, thumb turn inside, in satin nickel or satin stainless. Fits standard Schlage keys and matches our Schlage knobs and levers.

Kwikset 660 SmartKey single cylinder deadbolt in satin nickel

Kwikset 660 SmartKey deadbolt

Our price: $45.00

Single cylinder deadbolt in satin nickel with a 1 in. bolt throw and a rekeyable SmartKey cylinder, rated ANSI/BHMA Grade 3.

We can rekey a new lock to match the rest of your doors, and install it for you. Products you buy from us can be returned in person in Riverton within 30 days of pickup, unused and with all keys and packaging. See our return policy.

How to keep this from happening again

  • Keep your address, name, and plate number off your key ring.
  • Keep the garage remote in the car or on a separate ring from your house keys.
  • Have a spare house key made and keep it with someone you trust, not under the mat or a rock by the door.
  • Keep track of who has a key. If that list gets long, it may be time to rekey anyway.
  • Consider a keypad deadbolt or smart lock so a lost key isn't the only way in. See smart lock installation.

What to tell us when you call

  1. Your address in Riverton or the town you're in.
  2. Which doors the lost keys opened, and whether you still have a working key.
  3. The brand name on your key head, if you have one (Schlage, Kwikset, or another brand).
  4. Whether a garage remote, padlock keys, or work keys were on the ring.
  5. Whether you want all the doors on one key.

Spare Me Locksmith Services is a mobile-only locksmith based in Riverton, serving Riverton, Lander, Dubois, Shoshoni, and the rest of Fremont County. Fully insured, 100% satisfaction guaranteed, and an ALOA Security Professionals Association member #AR125851. Our hours are Monday through Friday from 8 AM and Saturday 9 AM to 2 PM; we are closed Sunday. For more of what we do for homes, see our residential locksmith page.

Frequently asked questions

Lost house key FAQ for Riverton & Fremont County

Not always. If there is any chance the keys can be tied to your address, such as keys lost with a wallet, ID, or mail, or lost near your home, rekey the locks they open. If it was one loose key with nothing on it, lost far from home, a spare from a key you still have may be enough.

Often yes, when the lock hardware is still in good shape. Rekeying changes the pins inside so the lost keys stop working while you keep the existing lock. Replacing costs more when you need new hardware. Call or text 307-206-4218 for a quote on your doors.

No. After a rekey, the old keys no longer open that lock. We cut new keys that match the new pin combination.

Yes, for many compatible locks. We can rekey the front, back, garage entry door, and deadbolts to the same key, so the new key ring is simpler.

Rekeying the house does not change the garage opener. We can remove the lost remote from your opener, program a replacement remote, and set up a wireless keypad.

We help with home and business lockouts in Riverton and Lander. Once you are in, we can rekey the locks so the lost key stops working and cut new keys. Call or text 307-206-4218 and tell us where you are.

Yes. Spare Me is a mobile locksmith. We come to your home or business anywhere we serve in Fremont County. There is no storefront to visit.

Contact us

Lost your house keys?

Tell us which doors the keys opened and what else was on the ring. We'll rekey your locks so the lost keys stop working, cut new keys, and clear a lost garage remote if you need it. Call or text 307-206-4218.

ALOA Security Professionals Association member #AR125851

ALOA Security Professionals Association member #AR125851

Get a quote

Request a locksmith quote

Tell us what you need and we will get back to you. Or call or text 307-206-4218.